Business monthly August 06
 
EDITOR'S NOTE COVER STORY EXECUTIVE LIFE
VIEWPOINT IN PERSON SUBSCRIPTION FORM
IN BRIEF MARKET WATCH ADVERTISING RATES
IN DEPTH CORPORATE CLINIC THE CHAMBER
FEATURE
 

IN DEPTH
Forex Bureaus Fight Capital Increase Pension Revision Shortchanges Seniors
New Code For Enviro Law Third Operator Dials In From Gulf
New Coinage Slow To Catch On  

BY AMENA BAKR

It has been two months since the Central Bank of Egypt (CBE) officially issued new coin versions of the £E 1 and 50-piastre notes, but millions of Egyptians have yet to handle the coins. According to the CBE, 3.5 million of the £E 1 coins and 2.2 million of the 50-piastre coin are already in circulation, compared to over 700 million £E 1 bank notes. Treasury officials say the plan is to steadily increase the number of new coins in circulation and, as the public gets used to them, phase out the equivalent bank notes within two years.

But the public’s response has been tepid at best. While some Egyptians were eager to see the new £E 1 and 50-piastre coins, imprinted with the faces of King Tut and Cleopatra respectively, many find them cumbersome and fear their issuance will lead to inflation. They argue that the conversion to coinage will give the impression that one pound is merely pocket change, having more in common with existing 5, 10 and 25 piastre coins than the larger £E 5 to £E 100 denomination bank notes. This perception will ultimately devalue the pound. “They [the government] are turning the pound into a coin just to prove to the people that it’s become totally worthless,” complains Atef Soliman, a 43-year-old grocery owner in downtown Cairo.

Treasury head Mostafa Ahmed dismisses the “conspiracy theories” that have surrounded the issuance of the new coins. “People have a psychological attachment to bills and feel that coins are worthless, which is not true,” he told Business Monthly. “The £E 1 [coin] will still have the same purchasing power as before.”

Ahmed explained that the main reason for the conversion to coinage was that bills were becoming increasingly expensive to print. He elaborates that complex anti-counterfeiting “blueprint” techniques and materials made the £E 1 bank note cost almost as much to print as its actual value. “Coins do not require blueprints and are generally harder to forge,” he says, adding that minting £E 1 coins is 60 percent cheaper than printing bills.

In addition, coins are far more durable than bank notes. Metal coins can stay in circulation for over 20 years; cotton-fiber bank notes by contrast rarely last two years in Egypt and by that time are usually torn, stitched together, filthy and faded. “This is a chance to get rid of all the tattered and torn £E 1 and 50-piastre bills that are out there, which are supposed to last for two years but actually last for much less,” he says.

To date, most of the coins in circulation have gravitated towards the lower income brackets, where citizens use small change for street food, shop purchases and transportation. Cairo’s underground subway system has already become accustomed to the new coinage, and reports no serious issues with it. “Whether we deal in £E 1 coins or notes it makes no significant difference to us,” insists Mahmoud Abdel Monem, Metro operations manager.

The higher volume of coins has some Metro officials thinking it’s time to invest in specially designed cases for cashiers, who currently keep coins and bills together in a drawer at their window. At the end of each day, the coins are sorted and wrapped, then sent to the bank, where they are counted manually. This could create a potential bottleneck, warns Abdel Monem, who expects automated counting machines to be introduced at banks as the number of coins in circulation increases.

A bigger issue, he argues, is the public’s rejection of 5 and 10 piastre bank notes, which were introduced in 1997 and have gained a reputation as Monopoly money. “Here at the Metro we accept them, but the majority of the passengers don’t want them back as change, and if they do accept them they use them to buy another Metro ticket because nobody else accepts them,” he says.

Mostafa Hussein, a 38-year-old kiosk owner, admits he outright refuses to accept 5 and 10 piastre bank notes. “At first I used to accept them, but when I found out that the banks don’t take them, I stopped taking them from my customers,” he explains.

Ahmed denies the widely-held perception that banks refuse to deal in the tiny bills. He urges customers and shop owners to insist on their right to use the legally tender bank notes. “The 5 and 10 piastre notes are real money and people should simply learn to fight harder for their rights so that shops and banks will accept them,” he says.

He confirmed that, for the time being at least, the CBE has no plans to stop the circulation of the small bills. Nor will it be deterred from its plan to replace £E 1 and 50-piastre bank notes with coins. “People have to get used to the idea of dealing with the new coins and the 5 and 10 piastre bills since they will be around for a while.”

Top

   
         Site Developed and Maintained by the Business Information Center of AmCham Egypt
Copyright©2007 American Chamber of Commerce in Egypt